Showing posts with label government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label government. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 1, 2012

The House Noone Built

The apologists for the President are now coming out of the woodwork regarding his "You didn't build that" quip, saying he just meant everyone has gotten a little help from friends and family to get where they are. Obviously, framed this way, it is very difficult to argue with such a blanket and relatively vanilla observation. Of course, to believe that you have to ignore not only what he said, but also the context in which he said it. Frankly, he said that if you have a successful business, it's not because of your own effort or attributes, but because government programs and infrastructure made it all possible.

The problem with this line of thinking is that government is overhead. It's a cost center, not a profit center. As James Madison said, "If men were angels, no government would be necessary" and we could reduce this cost to zero. However, that's not the case. We need a certain minimum level of government in order to create an environment conducive to economic growth (as illustrated by the Armey Curve).


Allow me to illustrate. A manufacturing company has an HR department, to handle the various needs involved in managing their people. If the company wanted to increase its productivity, it would not double the staffing in its HR department. If anything, they would look for ways to cut the HR budget to the minimum necessary to still have a well-managed workforce.

If a farmer wants to grow wheat, he needs fertile soil to create the right environment for growth. But at some point he actually needs to sow and water and harvest. Beyond a certain point, more soil doesn't help.

If I open a business in a shopping complex, can the landlord claim that I didn't build my business? Can he claim that if it wasn't for him, I wouldn't have a business? Can he lay claim to a percentage of my profits above and beyond whatever rent I've agreed to pay him? Can the business next door to mine claim a percentage of my profits because his rent helps pay for the entire building? The landlord may have created the conditions, but without my efforts it would just be an empty building. Unfortunately, today's political climate has made that a very common sight.

So, although we may derive benefits from government infrastructure, it doesn't produce growth by itself and actually crowds out alternative investments . Although other people have paid for it, we've paid for it too in the same taxes and fees that everyone else has. What no one else has shared is the risk I've taken, the hard work and perseverance I've applied, or the vision and the will to build. For two hundred years we've been the freest nation in the world and as a result have experienced the greatest boom of economic growth and technological innovation. Politicians didn't build that; the People did.

Saturday, April 21, 2012

To Support and Defend

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsberg's recent commentary on the Constitution has some people questioning her ability to uphold her oath, and with good reason.  "I would not look to the U.S. Constitution, if I were drafting a constitution in the year 2012." Instead "I might look at the constitution of South Africa."

A quick glance at the South African Constitution highlights some glaring differences from our own Constitution; differences which also highlight Ginsberg's unabashed political leanings.  South Africa guarantees its people food, water, education, housing and healthcare (among other things).  South African politicians are then charted to achieve these goals using their available resources.

The South African Constitution holds to the idea of "positive rights" which the left embraces and which FDR pushed for without our own government.  The key problem of course is that the government itself has nothing which it hasn't first taken from someone else.  In order to guarantee something to someone, you must first be willing to force someone to provide it, without regard for their personal liberty.

Frederic Bastiat succinctly describes the conflict between our Bill of Rights and FDR's "2nd Bill of Rights":

"The second half of your program will destroy the first."

In fact, it is impossible for me to separate the word fraternity from the word voluntary. I cannot possibly understand how fraternity can be legally enforced without liberty being legally destroyed, and thus justice being legally trampled underfoot.

Legal plunder has two roots: One of them, as I have said before, is in human greed; the other is in false philanthropy.

In fact, in order to enforce any sort of positive rights, you must first strip one group of their rights in order to satisfy another group, thereby failing the test of universality and putting to lie the idea of Equality before the law.  In doing so, the left clearly presupposes that some people are more equal than others.

Our Founding Fathers wrote the Constitution with an eye towards limiting government's potential for abuse, and by safeguarding Liberty they ensured an abundance of prosperity to their decedents.  If however we choose to sacrifice Liberty in order to gain material security, we will lose both.

Friday, March 16, 2012

Taxation With Representation


“No Taxation without Representation!” is one of the commonly referred to causes of the War for Independence.  This cry was largely rooted in John Locke’s assertion that a government forfeited its legitimacy when “any one shall claim a power to lay and levy taxes on the people, by his own authority, and without such consent of the people, he thereby invades the fundamental law of property, and subverts the end of government."

The issue of taxes and spending remained central to the political discussion after the war.  The Articles of Confederacy were purposefully weak in their ability to raise funds, to the point where it was difficult to discharge the debts incurred by the war itself.  Even so, the Constitution originally stated that "No Capitation, or other direct, Tax shall be laid, unless in proportion to the Census" and even then the funds could only be spent "to pay the Debts and provide for the... general Welfare of the United States."

It stands that the best kind of government spending is that which is approved by the majority of the people, with the costs equally shouldered across the people, and the benefits borne by the general people as a whole.

Any time one of those three criteria is compromised, the authority to tax and spend becomes perverted.

Less preferred, but still acceptable is when the benefits are reaped by a few, but those few bear the lion’s share of the costs.  User pays.  This is rare, however, because why would someone who had the ability and desire to pay for something decide to launder their money through the bureaucracy to do so?

No, in most cases special interests want to reap the benefit while forcing others to shoulder the costs.  When the tax-and-spend power of government is no longer paid by the People on behalf of the People, it becomes tantamount to theft by majority (in the case of popular support) or theft by the powerful (in the case of a small but politically influential group).  If history is any indicator, abusing the power of taxation eventually stirs the ire of the populace and undermines the very legitimacy of the government.

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Government Motors Wins Again

Let's recap, shall we?  Taxpayers were tapped to provide bailout money to cover for GM's poor decision making.  Then bondholders and pensioners were pinched to cover for GM's unsustainable union contracts (and potentially as a political "thank you" from the previous election).  Then taxpayers were hit up again to subsidize the Volt program specifically, whether they wanted to pay for an electric car or not.  After all of this, we wind up with a car that still costs about $10k more than its target market and randomly catches on fire.  Da Komrade, the system is working fine!

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-11-29/gm-s-volt-battery-fires-threaten-to-knock-moon-shot-off-target.html

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Freedom of Consent

We have to remember that the people in government are just like people in the corporate world.  They're ultimately self-interested.  They need to feel the connection between their actions and their consequences to make good decisions.  The difference is that we've entrusted them with coersive power; the authority to use force to compel us to do or not do certain things.  And power once ceded is rarely given back.  We really ought to remember that before inviting them into every aspect of our daily lives:

The problem... is that government is no different from any other organization in society -- it seeks its own aggrandizement. AT&T, General Motors, and Microsoft would love to have world monopolies, controlling all the resources and expanding into every corner of people's lives. But they are limited by competition, the dynamics of the marketplace, and the need to win people's consent in order to market their products.

Government is different. It expands by fiat, through legislation, through taking advantage of emergencies, and by declaring that private entities can't be trusted and government intervention is necessary. Most of all it grows by raising taxes and hiring more and more people so that soon its voter base approaches a majority of the electorate.
http://spectator.org/archives/2011/09/26/the-moochers-credo/

Let's face it.  It's easier to convince a majority of 435 people in Washington D.C. than it is to try to win the consent of millions of consumers exercising their freedom in the market.

Monday, October 10, 2011

Grading Solyndra on the Adoption Curve

So Solyndra goes bankrupt and the taxpayer is left holding the bag, to the tune of five-hundred million dollars ($500,000,000).  This really isn't a surprise and is a stellar example of why the free market, rather than government, is much better suited to speculative investment.  This is especially true in the case of technology.  Now, I'm a dollars and sense kind of guy, and I'll adopt "green" technologies when it makes sense.  Kinda like the commercial where all these folks are badgering this guy to "save the planet" and finally the technician says "The money you save on the washer will pay for the drier" and the guy says "Why didn't you say that in the first place?"

For example, ten years ago I looked at hybrids and there was just no way; they were too expensive.  Five years ago I looked again and I actually considered it; but the numbers still didn't quite work out.  I imagine in a few years the return on investment will be there and I'll buy some sort of low fuel consumption vehicle.  Until then, I'll keep driving my 27 mpg sedan.

This is known as the technology adoption curve:















Full Size Version

Once something becomes indisputably efficient and easy to adopt, it becomes mainstream and the majority of consumers buy it.  Until then, people buy the technology for other reasons: because it's "cool" or a status symbol, they like "new" things or because they want to make an investment (and possibly make a profit).

Those early adopters can afford to throw money away, and it's their choice to do so.  However, when government gets into the game it makes ALL of us into early adopters, whether we want to or not, whether we can afford it or not.  This sort of "venture cronyism" is a bad parody of its free-market equivalent.

I accept that businesses fail.  That doesn't bother me.  What makes me mad is that someone else forced me to cover a throw of the dice and they came out snake-eyes.

Friday, September 30, 2011

Successful Subsidized Energy? Not so fast...

The news coming out of the German energy market is a fascinating case study but it follows the typical pattern. Central planners decide they want to influence the supply and demand by manipulating producers and consumers. They are successful in that they get more of what they subsidize and less of what they penalize. However, they also have unintended consequences. In this case it is surpluses and shortages, reminiscent of the gas shortages of the 70s in the US and numerous other examples in the USSR. Laws are in place preventing the individuals from making adjustments to address the imbalance, in this case compulsory preference for the intermittent energy sources (solar and wind). Consumers still need a reliable source of energy that can pick up the slack when solar and wind are unavailable, but government interference is discouraging investing in conventional plants. Since the people are bound by law from fixing the problem it falls to the central planners to develop a solution. Their answer is as typical as it is ironic; subsidize coal plants.

But wait! Consumers are getting paid to use energy! They're getting it for free, right? Well not exactly. The subsidies aren't free; they are simply obfuscated by the tax code. Furthermore they represent a compulsory cost; what people pay to subsidize the energy industry is disassociated from their purchasing choices or their actual energy use.

The definition of insanity is doing the same things and expecting different results. Central planning consistently results in shortages and excesses, increased collective costs borne by the taxpayer, disenfranchising of the consumer and empowerment of the centralized planners and their crony capitalist / special interest lackeys. This latest example from Germany is no exception.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-09-29/utilities-giving-away-power-as-wind-sun-flood-european-grid.html

Thursday, September 15, 2011

Financing a $447 Billion Stimulus Injection

A recent article phrased the new stimulus plan as “injecting $447 billion into the economy,” which made me stop and think. Where exactly is this money coming from? I doubt the politicians in Washington are going to pay for it out of the vaults at Fort Knox (which would only cover about $278 billion or a little over half the bill anyway). That just leaves us with the three usual suspects; taxes, treasuries and the printing press.

Raiding private investment capital, ie: raising taxes, in order to “create jobs” is absurd. If the money was actually directed towards funding projects, it would simply mean diverting money from privately planned investment into politicians’ pet projects (a time-honored way of ensuring reelection). This plan will also use that money to extend unemployment checks, which is just as foolish. I would rather let someone buy a boat, thereby paying someone for building the boat, then tax the money away and hand it out as an unemployment check. However, this plan also includes tax cuts (without accompanying spending cuts), which leaves us with the other two options.

For the past few decades, we’ve gone to foreign investors to finance our government spending. The problem with this approach is two-fold. First, by competing for foreign investment dollars we crowd out private investment. In other words, businesses that are looking to finance expansion and real job creation are competing with the Federal government for the same scarce resource of investment capital. Secondly, those bonds incur interest payments down the road. That interest will have to be paid in the future from the same three sources (taxes, debt or inflation) which is the sort of kick-the-can politics that Washington D.C. loves.

That leaves the final source of funding; the printing press. The treasury prints the cash to cover the portion of the debt financed by the Federal Reserve. In simple terms, printing new money makes the money in savings and circulation worth less. Some people support this, since it makes our products cheaper for export. However, it makes everything we import (which is quite a lot these days) more expensive. It also hurts people living on fixed incomes and makes a joke out of long-term investment planning. In other words, it contributes to job-killing instability.

“Injecting” $447 billion really means deciding between taking domestic investment capital, competing for foreign investment capital, and pillaging our remaining savings. Instead of reactionary short-term fixes and more government controlled pork-barrel projects, we need to be thinking long-term. Stop spending taxes frivolously. Stop jerking the economic steering wheel by meddling with the currency. Return control (and money) to consumers and small businesses.  Let them drive the economy the way they’ve driven it since our national inception. They don’t need to be “stimulated” to make that work.

Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Make Mine Freedom

This is a fantastic cartoon.  It was true sixty years ago, just like it was true two hundred years ago and just like it's true today:

http://nationaljuggernaut.blogspot.com/2009/09/this-cartoon-seemed-far-fetched-in-1948.html

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Regulators: Insiders or Incompetents


Federal agencies regulating private businesses are inherently prone to abuse.  Ostensibly these agencies will root out corruption in the private sector, defending the little guy from the depredations of large corporations.  But to paraphrase Thomas Jefferson, where are we going to find these angels to watch over us?  The men appointed to these posts either come from the industries they are supposed to regulate, leading to conflicts of interest, or they have no background in the industry and are therefore incompetent.  In either case, while regulatory agencies are a convenient tool for politicians to change the rules of the game, they are unlikely to secure the public good.

The best candidate for a regulatory agent would have an extensive background in the field to be regulated.  To understand practical applications, his knowledge would have to be far more than academic.  Thus not only would he hold an appropriate degree but also have considerable experience practicing his trade.  Once appointed to public post and given the power to help or hinder his former colleagues, we expect him to suddenly sever all ties of affection and be an impartial arbiter.  Although in a perfect world the agent would be a neutral paragon of virtue, the reality is that most men will use their newfound power to reward friends and punish foes.

It might be tempting to choose an agent who had never formed such emotional ties in the field he is to be appointed over.  Armed perhaps with a basic degree in the field (if at all), his knowledge would be superficial at best.  Empowered and unguided, he would be like a child with a chainsaw; lacking mean intention but terribly dangerous nonetheless.  Alternatively, in seeking guidance from another he would place the powers of his office at the disposal of a stranger’s ambition.  The result: the agent’s power is either misguided or misused and fails to secure the public good as originally intended.

All acts of government carry with them the implicit use of force to fine or imprison.  Government’s acts are most proper when used as Rousseau describes in “defending and protecting with the total common force, the person and the property of each.”  However this power is abused when it is directed at furthering personal goals at the expense of the property of others.  Creating Federal agencies to interfere in business virtually ensures that agents will actively help or harm the industry they are to regulate; clearly an abuse of Government power.  We should not create agencies hoping to maximize the good if the office is held by a perfect man but rather to minimize the evil when the office is held by a flawed man.

Monday, May 17, 2010

Thomas Paine on War and Taxes

[Excerpts from Common Sense and from Rights of Man regarding war and taxes] 

Our plan is commerce, and that, well attended to, will secure us the peace and friendship of all Europe; because it is in the interest of all Europe to have America a free port.  Her trade will always be her protection...


[The government appears] to say to itself: "If nobody will be so kind as to become my foe, I shall need no more fleets or armies, and shall be forced to reduce my taxes."

...taxes were not raised to carry on wars, but that wars were raised to carry on taxes.

...if [the King] rashly declares war as a matter of right, and [Parliment] peremptorily withholds the supplies as a matter of right, the remedy becomes as bad, or worse, than the disease.  The one forces the Nation to combat, and the other ties its hands; but the more probable issue is that the contest will end in a collusion between the parties, and be made a screen to both.
[It is interesting to note that our Founding Fathers expressly vested the authority to commit the military in the Legislative to avoid this situation.

Congress shall have Power... To declare War, grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal, and make Rules concerning Captures on Land and Water;

For the past sixty years, however, the President has had the ability to commit the Armies, while the Legislative simply approves funding.  Supposedly this is a "check" on the President committing us to wars that are not in the best interest of the Nation, however as Mr. Paine points out, this is rarely the case in practice, since once committed it would be a churlish man indeed who denied supplies to Troops already engaged in combat.]

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Thomas Paine on Congress

[Excerpts from Common Sense and from Rights of Man regarding legislators]  
 ...that the elected might never form to themselves an interest separate from the electors... On this depends the strength of government, and the happiness of the governed.
...a body of men, holding themselves accountable to nobody, ought not to be trusted by any body.
When money is to be obtained, the mass of variety apparently dissolves, and a profusion of parliamentary praises passes between the parts.  Each admires with astonishment, the wisdom, the liberality, and disinterestedness of the other; and all of them breathe a pitying sigh at the burdens of the Nation.
Whether a combination acts to raise the price of any article for sale, or the rate of wages, or whether it acts to throw taxes from itself upon another class of the community, the principle and the effect are the same; and if the one be illegal, it will be difficult to shew that the other ought to exist.
It is from the power of taxation being in the hands of those who can throw so great a part of it from their own shoulders that it has raged without check.
...the portion of liberty enjoyed in England is just enough to enslave a country more productively than by despotism, and that as the real objective of all despotism is revenue, a Government so formed obtains more than it could either by direct despotism, or in a full state of freedom, and is, therefore, on the ground of interest, opposed to both.
[All courts and courtiers] form a common policy... detached and separate from the interest of Nations; and while they appear to quarrel, they agree to plunder.
What at first was plunder, assumed the softer name of revenue.
It is not because a part of the Government is elected, that makes it less despotism, if the persons so elected possess afterwards, as a Parliament, unlimited powers.
A man of moral honor and good political principles cannot submit to the mean drudgery and disgraceful arts by which such elections are carried.  To be a successful candidate he must be destitute of the qualities that constitute a just legislator; and being thus disciplined to corruption by the mode of entering Parliament, it is not to be expected that the representative should be better than the man.

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

Enumerated Powers in a Nutshell

I've taken the liberty of putting the enumerated powers of the Federal government in a short, easily read format...

These are our powers as individuals delegated to our representatives via the Constitution.
 
Not a very long list, is it?

The President can…
  • veto laws
  • issue pardons
  • establish a cabinet of principle advisers
  • act as military commander in chief
  • ratify treaties (with the consent of the Senate)
  • appoint judges, ambassadors, consuls, ministers and other officers (with the consent of the Senate)
  • give the State of the Union speech
  • convene or adjourn both Houses
  • receive Ambassadors and other public Ministers
  • take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed
  • Commission all the Officers of the ....United States.....

Congress can…
  • override a presidential veto
  • collect taxes, borrow money & set monetary policy
  • fix weights and standards
  • regulate international and interstate trade
  • provide for the common defense
  • establish a uniform rule of naturalization,
  • establish uniform laws on the subject of bankruptcies
  • establish post offices and post roads;
  • provide for patents and copyrights
  • constitute tribunals inferior to the Supreme Court;
  • manage the Capital and other Federal buildings

The Federal Courts can rule on…
  • cases under the Federal Constitution, laws, and treaties
  • cases involving ambassadors
  • cases involving navigable waters
  • cases in which the ....United States.... is a party
  • cases between two or more states
  • cases between citizens of different states
  • cases between citizens claiming land in different states
  • cases between citizens or states and foreign citizens or states

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Thomas Paine on Government


[Enjoy these excerpts from the man of whom John Adams said "Without the pen of Paine the sword of Washington would have been wielded in vain."]

Thomas Paine regarding the Nature of Government:

Government even in its best state is but a necessary evil; in its worst state an intolerable one.

When men think of Government, they must necessarily suppose it to possess a knowledge of all the objects and matters upon which its authority is to be exercised.

Laws difficult to be executed cannot be generally good.

Everything which Government can usefully add thereto, has been performed by the common consent of society, without Government.

If we look back to the riots and tumults which at various times have happened in England, we shall find that they did not proceed from the want of a Government, but that Government was itself the generating cause.

Every man wishes to pursue his occupation, and to enjoy the fruits of his labours and the produce of his property in peace and safety, and with the least possible expense. When these things are accomplished, all objectives for which Government ought to be established are answered.

Search Engine Submission - AddMe