Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Thursday, November 1, 2012

Regression to Serfdom

The market has failed. That's a frequent justification for expanding the powers granted to politicians. But how has the market failed? By who's standards? When we miss a hole in one do we talk about "physics failure?" Or if we can't balance the checkbook is it a "failure of mathematics?" What it really means is that people's interactions haven't produced the results the speaker wanted. But how often do these same folks talk about legislative failure? About programs and politics that have unintended consequences?

These days it is rare that people seize power by force of arms. The people violently wrested power from the ruling class in a series of revolts over hundreds of years. Now, the approach of the ruling class is to convince the people to freely gift that power back to the government, where it can be conveniently bought and sold. As I've said before, when you hear "the free market has failed" just mentally substitute "freedom has failed" and you'll begin to see through the lies used to convince us to return to serfdom.

"Is not this simpler? Is this not your natural state? It's the unspoken truth of humanity, that you crave subjugation. The bright lure of freedom diminishes your life's joy in a mad scramble for power, for identity. You were made to be ruled." - Loki

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

The Politics of Bribery

"Many states believe there is little choice involved when the federal government has the power to tax citizens in the states, returning that money only if states comply with ever-increasing... mandates."

And that right there is the problem in a nutshell.  The Founding Fathers were clear that the Federal government would only have the power to spend money on the common defense and the general welfare and that it would only be able to raise funds expressly to pay those bills.  "General welfare" meaning for the benefit of all; not the majority, not the special interests, but for all.

Unfortunately, the result has been a government of good intentions, spending money on whatever program will help a politician curry votes.  Ironically if everyone plays beggar-thy-neighbor politics, we all get equally robbed!  The only difference is that people tend to be irresponsible with "free" money, with the predictable result of blossoming Federal spending.

The State governments themselves are even worse about helping themselves to the public trough; they get to fund programs without appearing responsible for the taxes.

The 16th Amendment allowed the Federal government to reach past the States, directly into the pockets of the citizens and then use that money to bribe the States into compliance with any number of unconstitutional mandates claiming it was just using the authority to "tax."  Fortunately more and more States are realizing that there is no such things as a free lunch and that these dollars come at a cost; to our freedom and our sovereignty.  However many people are already hooked, and the withdrawel symptoms won't be painless.  Let's hope we have the fortitude to stick it out; otherwise the States will continue to be puppets of the Feds instead of the check-and-balance they were intended to be.

Friday, March 16, 2012

Taxation With Representation


“No Taxation without Representation!” is one of the commonly referred to causes of the War for Independence.  This cry was largely rooted in John Locke’s assertion that a government forfeited its legitimacy when “any one shall claim a power to lay and levy taxes on the people, by his own authority, and without such consent of the people, he thereby invades the fundamental law of property, and subverts the end of government."

The issue of taxes and spending remained central to the political discussion after the war.  The Articles of Confederacy were purposefully weak in their ability to raise funds, to the point where it was difficult to discharge the debts incurred by the war itself.  Even so, the Constitution originally stated that "No Capitation, or other direct, Tax shall be laid, unless in proportion to the Census" and even then the funds could only be spent "to pay the Debts and provide for the... general Welfare of the United States."

It stands that the best kind of government spending is that which is approved by the majority of the people, with the costs equally shouldered across the people, and the benefits borne by the general people as a whole.

Any time one of those three criteria is compromised, the authority to tax and spend becomes perverted.

Less preferred, but still acceptable is when the benefits are reaped by a few, but those few bear the lion’s share of the costs.  User pays.  This is rare, however, because why would someone who had the ability and desire to pay for something decide to launder their money through the bureaucracy to do so?

No, in most cases special interests want to reap the benefit while forcing others to shoulder the costs.  When the tax-and-spend power of government is no longer paid by the People on behalf of the People, it becomes tantamount to theft by majority (in the case of popular support) or theft by the powerful (in the case of a small but politically influential group).  If history is any indicator, abusing the power of taxation eventually stirs the ire of the populace and undermines the very legitimacy of the government.

Friday, December 30, 2011

Faust's Bargain: Charity and Government

The latest edition of Columbia includes an article by Alton J. Pelowski entitled "In Defense of Life, Love and Freedom" describing the problems when a private charity becomes dependent on public funding.  Similarly, Catholic Charities in Illinois are closing their adoption services because of new requirements to change their screening criteria to accept gay couples in order to receive government funding.

Although I empathize with their distress, American Catholics who have traditionally supported government-sponsored social programs have only themselves to blame.  Non-profit organizations who have been happy to trade arduous fund-raising for siphoning tax revenues are likewise guilty.

"Free money" is always hard to resist, but there's always a catch.  Once you've accepted the money you lose the freedom to run your organization as you like (which is why some organizations like Hillsdale College eschew public funding).

Indeed, the Catholic charities are faced with a dilemma of their own making.  If they refuse to  compromise their principles for money, they must either close their doors or return to the days when they relied on their own voluntary fund-raising efforts.  The latter option is obviously more difficult; a consequence of diverting funds from private donations to publicly mandated tax revenue.

Instead it looks like they're taking the easy option: quitting.

Monday, October 10, 2011

Grading Solyndra on the Adoption Curve

So Solyndra goes bankrupt and the taxpayer is left holding the bag, to the tune of five-hundred million dollars ($500,000,000).  This really isn't a surprise and is a stellar example of why the free market, rather than government, is much better suited to speculative investment.  This is especially true in the case of technology.  Now, I'm a dollars and sense kind of guy, and I'll adopt "green" technologies when it makes sense.  Kinda like the commercial where all these folks are badgering this guy to "save the planet" and finally the technician says "The money you save on the washer will pay for the drier" and the guy says "Why didn't you say that in the first place?"

For example, ten years ago I looked at hybrids and there was just no way; they were too expensive.  Five years ago I looked again and I actually considered it; but the numbers still didn't quite work out.  I imagine in a few years the return on investment will be there and I'll buy some sort of low fuel consumption vehicle.  Until then, I'll keep driving my 27 mpg sedan.

This is known as the technology adoption curve:















Full Size Version

Once something becomes indisputably efficient and easy to adopt, it becomes mainstream and the majority of consumers buy it.  Until then, people buy the technology for other reasons: because it's "cool" or a status symbol, they like "new" things or because they want to make an investment (and possibly make a profit).

Those early adopters can afford to throw money away, and it's their choice to do so.  However, when government gets into the game it makes ALL of us into early adopters, whether we want to or not, whether we can afford it or not.  This sort of "venture cronyism" is a bad parody of its free-market equivalent.

I accept that businesses fail.  That doesn't bother me.  What makes me mad is that someone else forced me to cover a throw of the dice and they came out snake-eyes.

Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Make Mine Freedom

This is a fantastic cartoon.  It was true sixty years ago, just like it was true two hundred years ago and just like it's true today:

http://nationaljuggernaut.blogspot.com/2009/09/this-cartoon-seemed-far-fetched-in-1948.html

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

Marx vs. Smith

Key to Marxism is the argument that the laborer has always been forced to work for the bourgeoisie. Although true in the days of slavery and serfdom, when those in power used violence to extract labor, it is a stretch to believe this is true today. The “force” supposedly compelling today’s laborer is the threat of unemployment. However, as Adam Smith points out in Wealth of Nations, man in his natural state works only for himself. Therefore, the alternative to employment is not death by starvation as the Marxists claim, but rather that which man naturally possesses: self-employment. Ironically, those in power are willing to raise taxes on the self-employed Americans that make up 70% of the “businesses” in the United States. At least they have generously offered to return some of those tax dollars, for a small fee; in the form of small business loans.
Search Engine Submission - AddMe